Teams 
| Year | All-Stars (Pos.) |
|---|---|
| 2011 | Jose Bautista (OF), Ricky Romero (P) |
| 2010 | Jose Bautista (OF), John Buck (C), Vernon Wells (OF) |
| 2009 | Aaron Hill (2B), Roy Halladay (P) |
| 2008 | Roy Halladay (P) |
| 2007 | Alex Rios (OF) |
| 2006 | Troy Glaus (3B), Roy Halladay (P), B.J. Ryan (P), Alex Rios (OF), Vernon Wells (OF) |
| 2005 | Roy Halladay (P), Shea Hillenbrand (DH) |
| 2004 | Ted Lilly (P) |
| 2003 | Carlos Delgado (1B), Roy Halladay (P), Vernon Wells (OF) |
| 2002 | Roy Halladay (P) |
| 2001 | Paul Quantrill (P) |
| 2000 | Tony Batista (3B), Carlos Delgado (1B), David Wells (P) |
| 1999 | Tony Fernandez (3B), Shawn Green (OF) |
| 1998 | Roger Clemens (P) |
| 1997 | Roger Clemens (P), Pat Hentgen (P) |
| 1996 | Joe Carter (OF) |
| 1995 | Roberto Alomar (2B) |
| 1994 | Roberto Alomar (2B), Joe Carter (OF), Pat Hentgen (P), Paul Molitor (DH) |
| 1993 | Roberto Alomar (2B), Joe Carter (OF), Pat Hentgen (P), Paul Molitor (DH), John Olerud (1B), Duane Ward (P), Devon White (OF) |
| 1992 | Roberto Alomar (2B), Joe Carter (OF), Juan Guzman (P) |
| 1991 | Roberto Alomar (2B), Joe Carter (OF), Jimmy Key (P) |
| 1990 | George Bell (OF), Kelly Gruber (3B), Dave Stieb (P) |
| 1989 | Tony Fernandez (SS), Kelly Gruber (3B) |
| 1988 | Dave Stieb (P) |
| 1987 | George Bell (OF), Tony Fernandez (SS), Tom Henke (P) |
| 1986 | Jessie Barfield (OF), Tony Fernandez (SS), Lloyd Moseby (OF) |
| 1985 | Damaso Garcia (2B), Jimmy Key (P), Dave Stieb (P), Ernie Whitt (C |
| 1984 | Damaso Garcia (2B), Alfredo Griffin (SS), Dave Stieb (P) |
| 1983 | Dave Stieb (P) |
| 1982 | Jim Clancy (P) |
| 1981 | Dave Stieb (P) |
| 1980 | Dave Stieb (P) |
| 1979 | Dave Lemanczyk (P) |
| 1978 | Roy Howell (3B) |
| 1977 | Ron Fairly (OF) |
